Thursday, 20 February 2014

Note Making Skills Make You Better Learners !




These Symbols will make things easier!

It is important for students of all grades and subjects to develop skills in note-making and note-taking. Developing sound Note Making skills can be the key to understanding comprehension passages, treatises and many other texts.  Although the CBSE has removed note-taking in Grade twelve for the session 2020-2021, it is important to note that simply ignoring note-taking skills can be highly detrimental. Note-taking helps you identify the key points in the passage, and it helps you break up the passage into its key components. Developing note-making skills helps you summarise what you have read in roughly one-third of the number of words used in the passage. The Summary, which follows after you have written down the notes, is the final step in note-taking. Note-taking and summarising are two important skills that should be taught in earlier grades, like eighth and ninth. Note-making is an essential tool that helps students understand difficult treatises, passages and research passages in different subjects, not just English.

Learning Tasks:

1. The whole passage is read quickly and then the student tries to identify the Key Paragraph that contains the Nucleus Sentence. It is from the key paragraph that the student is also able to draw a title. In many cases, the key paragraph might be the first paragraph.
2. The passage is then divided into headings and subheadings ( I, II,III, IV, V, or 1,2,3,4,5). The numbers are listed on the outside of the margin.
3. Supporting sub-points are then listed in numerical order (1, 2, 3 under the first heading, then 1, 2, 3…etc. In some cases, there might be sub-subpoints where points might be listed as 1.1., 1.2., and sub-sub-sub 1.1.1., 1.1.2., 1.1.3., …etc. Depending on how these sub-subpoints develop. The numbers are listed inside the margins.
4. The students will use recognisable abbreviations and symbols in order to write down the notes in a contracted form.
5. The next task, following the note-making exercise, will include the drafting of the summary based strictly on the notes prepared by the student. The student should note that the word limit should not be exceeded, as marks will be deducted. Also, students should avoid repetition of ideas and make good use of sentence connectors to join sentences, thus avoiding too many repetitions of words.

Important Note: Generally, each paragraph is devoted to one topic. However, the same topic might be shared by one or more paragraphs. In such a case, students can merge two or more paragraphs under one topic sentence.
The marks distribution for the twelfth board CBSE paper is as follows:
1.       Title: 1 mark
2.       Notes ( at least three headings and the notes under them):2 marks (Content 1 Marks + 1 Mark   Coherence) Coherence refers to the listing, alignment, overall neatness.
3.       List of abbreviations (minimum 4) in a box: 1 mark
4.       Summary: 4 marks

Important: the final notes will be in the form of a linear listing of points, or in a branched format. A typical note-taking exercise in the linear format will look as follows:

Title:
1. Nucleus Sentence
   1.1 sub- point
   1.2 sub- point
   1.3 sub- point
2. Topic Sentence
   2.1 sub- point
   2.2 sub- point
   2.3 sub- point
3. Topic Sentence
   3.1 sub-point
   3.2 sub-point…and so on.

Important: Remember that notes that come under the headings (sub-points) cannot be written as sentences. Notes should be written only as phrases. As such, one needs to remember that full stops will not be used. Also, ensure that each sub-point is short and doesn't run into more than one line at the most!


Important Tips
The length of the notes will depend upon the length of the passage. The student will avoid noting down points which are being repeated for the sake of brevity. Also, use recognisable abbreviations, and avoid the use of articles, prepositions and conjunctions. This, however, does not mean that your notes are vague to the reader. Your notes should make sense to the examiner when he or she goes through them. Also, remember that you are not allowed to use sentences in note-taking. You need to identify the main points and not entire sentences. You need to have a minimum of three main headings. You need to have a minimum of four abbreviations. Remember to indent the notes properly.


Standard recognizable abbreviations for countries include U.P. U.K.
Standard abbreviations for titles include: Mr, Mrs, Ms, Dr, Messrs...etc
Common symbols include: &, +ve, -ve, >,<, ...etc
Common measurements: kg, lb, sq.ft. mm, ml, ...etc.



The Passage given below is in the form of an example. Go through it carefully and see how the Headings have been listed, followed by their supporting value points:


Strategic planning is typically thought of in terms of how large businesses and nations design a plan of action to accomplish their specific goals -- but it is a fabulous tool for individuals as well. If you find yourself disappointed by your life, consider taking a look at how strategically you are living it.
Some people worry that being strategic is about being manipulative. Certainly, there is a fine balance between passivity and trying to live life according to the "my way or the highway" approach to influencing the course of events. I think of being strategic as actively engaging in shaping and directing your life. It is about being thoughtful, careful, and purposeful -- the antithesis of simply drifting along being caught up in whatever situations and circumstances you happen to bump into in the course of your life. Strategic living means being smart enough to embrace the opportunity of playing an active role in determining what you are creating, promoting and allowing in your life.
If you were investing in a business, wouldn't you want to know that it was being run by individuals who were well-versed regarding the opportunities and challenges they faced? Wouldn't you want them to use their resources (people, money and time) in such a way that they maximised the company's short- and long-term return on investment? Most likely, it would be important to you that these returns be measured not just in terms of money, but relative to such other factors as alignment with the company's mission, and their commitment to such values as integrity, social consciousness and the quality of their relationships with employees and other stakeholders.
Now, let's apply this thinking to how you assess your own life choices. Being strategic is about getting off autopilot behaviour and being thoughtful about the choices you make in your life. It means living within the context of having a good understanding of who you are, what matters to you, and what resources and options you have available.
As a life coach, I work with this perspective as a means of increasing my clients' self-awareness, well-being, enjoyment and creative self-empowerment. Making thoughtful and strategic choices about how you live your life can have an enormous impact on your level of satisfaction and enjoyment.

There are three fundamental, ongoing, and interrelated activities involved in strategically living your life. They are: creating a plan, keeping track of results and altering your course based on those results and the unanticipated surprises life brings your way. A good strategist needs a great sense of humour and an appreciation for the power of the unknown because no matter how thoughtful and thorough your planning techniques, life will throw you curveballs. It's humbling, but the alternative of having no plan means being at the mercy of your life rather than being an active participant and driving force.

Our lives tend to be very complex and to include conflicting priorities and demands on our time. A seasoned life strategist is like a juggler trying to simultaneously stay on course with specific plans for each major aspect of his or her life. For example, you might have plans for your spiritual life, family, career, finances, etc. For a novice planner, I suggest picking one area of your life where you are experiencing the greatest challenges and starting there. As you stabilize one area of your life, develop a plan for another aspect and learn to develop skills in making the trade-offs that are necessary between the various aspects of your life.
(This article, written by Judith Johnson was posted on “The Blog, Huff post-Healthy Living” on 09/26/2013 12:17 pm)

Task 1: Identifying a suitable title from the passage

The importance of Strategic Planning
How we benefit from Strategic Planning

Benefits of Strategic Planning


Important Note: Avoid single-word titles. There should be a minimum of at least two words. Remember, your titles are important. Vague titles indicate confusion.
Task 2: Write notes under each heading from the passage

1. What is Strategic planning?
  1.1 plan of action
  1.2 tool for large org. & nations
  1.3 tool for ind.
2. Why is Strategic Planning important for people?
  2.1 helps bal. b/w passivity & trying to live acc.
  2.2 Antithesis to simply drifting
  2.3 smartness to embrace opportunities

3. Importance of Strategic Planning in Business
   3.1 provides knowledge about employees
   3.2 maximise short/long-term investments
4. Three fundamental steps in Strategic Planning
    4.1 Creating a plan
    4.2 Keeping track of results
    4.3 Altering course based on results
5.  How can we plan for complexities in life?
    5.1 Pick one area of life which is most challenged
    5.2 Start planning for it
    5.3 When you stabilise that area, dev. plan for another aspect
    5.4 Learn to dev. Skills in making trade-offs b/w various aspects of life


One example of the branched format for note-making is given as follows:

Title: Strategic Planning



There are interesting ways of making notes, but then, if it is about appearing for a specific exam, then the student will have to enquire about the formats that will be accepted by the examiner. Generally, the CBSE accepts the linear form of making notes.



Task 3: Draw a list or key for the abbreviations used by you in your notes

List of abbreviations:
1.b/w   :  between
2.ind.  :  individual
3. acc:  according
4. dev. :  develop
5. inv.  :  investment
Task 4: Draft a summary of the notes you made
 Write the summary in a specific number of words. In this case, the total number of words is a hundred and twenty. Note: remember to write the summary from the notes you have made, and try to stick to the word limit. The grid is for representational purposes and it can be drawn with a pencil and then rubbed off! Drawing a grid will help the student to stick to the word limit and a quick calculation will determine the number of rows and columns required. In this case, the student is required to write a summary in 120 words, so eight columns and fifteen rows will give you 120 boxes in which you can write 120 words. The advantage of using a grid is that it guides you about the number of words you have written without making you pause and count each word! You get a visual feel about how much space is left. To keep the summary short, avoid repeating ideas, use connectors like and, which, because, since, however, to join sentences.
Strategic
planning
refers
to
a
plan
of
Action.
It
Is
an
important
tool
used
by
large
organisations
industries
nations
and
Individual.
It
Is
important
because
it
provides
a
balance
between
passivity
and
living
according
to

Plan.
Strategic
planning
leads
to
smartness
in
embracing
Opportunities.
Planning
Is
important
in
business
because
you
need
to
know
the
individual
and
you
need
to
maximise
Short-term
and
Long-term
Investments.
The
three
fundamental
activities
in
planning
include
creating
a
plan,
keeping
track
of
results
and
altering
course
based
on
results.
One
can
plan
for
a
complicated
life
by
picking
up
an
area
of
life
that
is
most
challenged
and
starting
to
plan
for
specific
areas.
When
one
area
is
Stabilized,
start
on
the
other!

Total: 120 words

Important tips for the summary: 
The summary is made up entirely of the notes.
Paraphrase rather than copy the exact words of the author of the passage.
Use liberal use of linkers or connectors to reduce repetitions.
Don't compromise on fluency.
Write complete sentences, avoid using abbreviations and symbols.
Use third-person narration, indirect speech and past tense where required.
Supply a suitable title, not in one word, but at least a couple of words or a phrase.
Do not exceed the word limit of 80 words.

Exercise 1
Read the following passage carefully:



By Jen Laskey/Medically reviewed by Sanjai Sinha, MD

1. Did you know that your body weight is approximately 60 per cent water? Your body uses water in all its cells, organs, and tissues to help regulate its temperature and maintain other bodily functions. Because your body loses water through breathing, sweating, and digestion, it's important to rehydrate by drinking fluids and eating foods that contain water. The amount of water you need depends on a variety of factors, including the climate you live in, how active you are, and whether you are experiencing an illness or have any other health problems.

2. Water does more than just quench your thirst and regulate your body's temperature; it also keeps the tissues in your body moist. You know how it feels when your eyes, nose, or mouth get dry! Keeping your body hydrated helps it retain optimum levels of moisture in these sensitive areas, as well as in the blood, bones, and the brain. In addition, water helps protect the spinal cord, and it acts as a lubricant and cushion for your joints.

3. Adequate water intake enables your body to excrete waste through perspiration, urination, and defecation. The kidneys and liver use it to help flush out waste, as do your intestines. Water can also keep you from getting constipated by softening your stools and helping move the food you've eaten through your intestinal tract. However, it should be noted that there is no evidence to prove that increasing your fluid intake will cure constipation.

4. Digestion starts with saliva, the basis of which is water. Digestion relies on enzymes that are found in saliva to help break down food and liquid and to dissolve minerals and other nutrients. Proper digestion makes minerals and nutrients more accessible to the body. Water is also necessary to help you digest soluble fibre. With the help of water, this fibre dissolves easily and benefits your bowel health by making well-formed, soft stools that are easy to pass.

5. Your body loses fluids when you engage in vigorous exercise, sweat in high heat, or come down with a fever or contract an illness that causes vomiting or diarrhoea. If you're losing fluids or for any of these reasons, it is important to increase your fluid intake so that you can restore your body's natural hydration levels. Your doctor may also recommend that you drink more fluids to help treat other health conditions, like bladder infections and urinary tract stones. If you're pregnant or nursing, you may want to consult your physician about your fluid intake because your body will be using more fluids than usual, especially if you're breastfeeding.

6. There's no hard and fast rule, and many individuals meet their daily hydration needs by simply drinking water when they're thirsty, according to a report on nutrient recommendations from the Institute of Medicine of the National Academies. In fact, most people who are in good physical health get enough fluids by drinking water and other beverages when they are thirsty, and also by drinking a beverage with each of their meals, according to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention. If you are not sure about your hydration level, look at urine. If it is clear, you are in good shape. If It is dark, you are probably dehydrated.

1. Prepare notes on the above passage. Remember to supply a suitable title for the passage. (4 Marks)

2. Draft a summary in not more than 100 words for the above passage. (4 Marks)


There are some more passages for practice below.

Read the following passage carefully and answer the questions that follow.
 1. How does television affect our lives? It can be very helpful for people who carefully choose the shows that they watch. Television can increase our knowledge of the outside world; there are high-quality programmes that help us understand many fields of study, science, medicine, the different arts and so on. Moreover, television benefits very old people, who can’t leave the house, as well as patients in hospitals. It also offers non-native speakers the advantage of daily informal language practice. They can increase their vocabulary and practise listening.
2. On the other hand, there are several serious disadvantages of television. Of course, it provides us with a pleasant way to relax and spend our free time, but in some countries, people watch television for an average of six hours or more a day. Many children stare at the TV screen for more hours a day than they spend on anything else, including studying and sleeping. It’s clear that TV has a powerful influence on their lives and that its influence is often negative.
3. Recent studies show that after only thirty seconds of television viewing, a person’s brain ‘relaxes’ in the same way that it does just before the person falls asleep. Another effect of television on the human brain is that it seems to cause poor concentration. Children who view a lot of television can often concentrate on a subject for only fifteen to twenty minutes. They can pay attention only for the amount of time between commercials.
4. Another disadvantage is that television often causes people to become dissatisfied with their own lives. Real-life does not seem exciting to these people. To many people, television becomes more real than reality and their own lives seem boring. Also, many people get upset or depressed when they can’t solve problems in real life as quickly as television actors seem to.
5. Before a child is fourteen years old, he or she views eleven thousand murders on TV. He or she begins to believe that there is nothing strange about fights, killings and other kinds of violence. Many studies show that people become more violent after viewing certain programmes. They may even do the things that they see in a violent show.

1. Prepare notes on the above passage. Remember to supply a suitable title for the passage. (4 Marks)

2. Draft a summary in not more than 100 words for the above passage. (4 Marks)


Read the passage carefully and answer the questions that follow.

1. Some people say that the best defence is a good offence; an octopus, however, would disagree. In addition to being one of the strangest and most beautiful creatures in nature, the octopus has some of the most inventive and effective defence mechanisms imaginable. While other animals have teeth, horns, or claws to help defend themselves from predators, the octopus concentrates its energy on hiding from and confusing its attackers. When it wants to get away, the octopus has an impressive arsenal of tricks at its disposal.
2. The most well-known of the octopus’s defence mechanisms is its ability to squirt clouds of ink into the water. Some octopi use this cloud of ink as camouflage; after squirting the ink, the octopus retreats into the ink cloud, where the predator cannot see it. Other octopuses use the ink cloud as a decoy. If a large, intelligent predator such as a shark knows that octopi use ink clouds for camouflage, it might simply attack the ink cloud blindly, hoping to make contact with the octopus inside. However, some sneaky octopi will release the ink cloud in one direction and scurry away in another direction, leaving the predator with nothing but a mouthful of ink. In addition to confusing predators’ sense of sight, these ink clouds also confuse their sense of smell. The ink is composed primarily of melanin (the same chemical that gives human skin its colour), which can shut down a predator’s sense of smell. If an octopus cannot be seen or smelled, it has a much higher chance of escaping an attack.
 3. Camouflage, another defence mechanism possessed by many octopi, refers to their ability to change colour, much like a chameleon. Most animals get their skin colour from chemicals in the skin called chromatophores (melanin is one of these chromatophores). Chromatophores might contain yellow, orange, red, brown, or black pigments, and the amount of each pigment present in the skin determines an animal’s colour. While most animals are always the same colour, some species of octopi can control the amount of each colour pigment in their skin cells, allowing them to change colour. Some poisonous octopi, when provoked, will change their skin to a bright, eye-catching colour to warn predators that they are dangerous and ready to strike. Other octopi use this ability to change their skin to the colour and texture of seaweed or coral, allowing them to blend in with their environment. Finally, some octopi—such as the mimic octopus—use this colour-changing ability to masquerade as another type of animal. The body of an octopus is highly flexible, and some species can combine this flexibility with their colour-changing skills to make themselves resemble more dangerous animals such as sea snakes or eels.
4. Yet another defence mechanism possessed by some octopus is the ability to perform autotomy, or self-amputation, of one of their limbs and regrow it later. Many species of skink and lizard also possess this ability, which allows them to shed their tails when caught by a predator and therefore get away. When a predator catches a tentacle, the octopus can amputate this tentacle, thereby unfettering itself, and regrow the tentacle later. Some octopus, however, are even cleverer. When threatened by a predator, these octopi will shed a tentacle before being attacked in the hope that the predator will go after the detached tentacle rather than the octopus itself.
5. While the octopus may not be the most vicious creature in the ocean, its numerous and clever defence mechanisms help it to survive in the dangerous undersea world.

1. Prepare notes on the above passage. Remember to supply a suitable title for the passage. (4 Marks)

2. Draft a summary in not more than 100 words for the above passage. (4 Marks)



III. Read the following passage carefully and answer the questions that follow.
1. Given the general awareness of the woeful condition of our State schools, it would be surprising to find someone not engaging a private tutor or two, if he could afford it. We, the urban, articulate and decision-making top 5% of Indians, perfectly understand why only the rarest of rare among our politicians and bureaucrats send their children to a state school. They’re not for people like us; they’re for people like them. And so, in 21st-century India, we are immune to the fact that the vast majority of Indians will be educationally deficient, uncompetitive in most contemporary skills and quite unable to raise their standards of living through the straight route.
2. Our complacency does not get shaken by the alarming rate of growth of the private tuition industry. This industry is exploiting the mediocrity that has spread even to our private schools. Attempts by the state governments to ban private tuition have failed because the schools’ managements don’t cooperate. Indeed, they often sabotage these moves. The common practice is to first deny the teachers their just wages and then look the other way when they try to make it up by giving private tuitions. In some states, teachers are forced to sign bonds that bar them from giving private coaching, but this promise remains on paper.
3. Parents are both perpetrators and victims of this pernicious system. The hedonism bred by free-market principles has led to the commodification of education. Those who can afford it, recruit private tutors because it gives their children an edge in competitive examinations.  The vast majority of people cannot afford tuition and, therefore, fall behind. The national objective of the society, where every child gets equal opportunity, is lost.
4. When the NCERT began working on developing a new National Curriculum Framework in 1999, one of the objectives was that the course content should be set keeping in mind contemporary realities and global trends. To have both parents working is more the norm than the exception in modern India. The pressures of the workplace don’t allow mothers the time to assist their children anymore. To prevent young parents from falling into the tuition trap, several steps, including the introduction of grades in place of marks, were recommended. Long-forgotten recommendations made on education, like the Yash Pal Committee’s report of 1990, which recommended lighter school bags, were brought out of the backburners.

a) Based on your reading of the above passage, make notes on it using headings and subheadings. Use recognisable abbreviations (minimum four) and a format you consider suitable. Supply a suitable title for it.                                                                                                                                               5 Marks                                                                                                                                      
b) Make a summary for your passage based on your notes                                                           3 Marks 

                                                                          



Thursday, 6 February 2014

Is it the Media that Spoils the Society or, is it the Society that spoils the Media?

- A circular question, dangerous to get into, and once in, you would never be able to get out of it! A rhetorical question gone bad, twisted logic,  twisted analogy; akin to getting to prove the statement, ‘You need light to read, feathers are light, so you need feathers to read!’ wrong! The irony of the above statement came to light during a debate session that I was undertaking with my grade nine students in English.The matter came to a head when one group young and zesty debaters entered into a lively discussion about  whether the ‘Media is to Blame for the crimes taking place in the society’-the topic of the debate for the day. They were very polite in their interjections, observations and rebuttals and very passionate too, but then I knew very well that I would have to step in at some time or the other knowing well that the debate could go on and on endlessly like a perpetual pendulum.A highly controversial topic, and the teacher was fully aware about the storm it was likely to create.
One enterprising student talked about how some films had a bad effect on impressionable young minds and how he was aghast on watching  ‘American Pie’. A student from the audience making the interjection literally tore him to bits by asking him what he was doing watching a film that was meant for adults! Another observation was that if the media did have a negative influence on young and impressionable minds, you still had the choice and sense of not going for them! However the fact of the matter is that young students have curious minds, and they would be always curious about the contents of a ‘forbidden or out of bounds’ box. Another debater, a girl however stated quite frankly that she thought that the media was not bad, it was merely a mirror of the society and was in essence it was only what was a reality. To this argument, another student interjected with the statement that it was the responsibility of the media to portray only that with was good, and to this there was a follow up by yet another student suggesting stricter censorship norms. The debate went on, and yet another student made an observation that censorship would be detrimental to the freedom of the media to portray the world as it is, and that censoring would only provide an unfair and inaccurate picture of the world! Observers, debaters and  those making interjections came to the conclusion that the medial including newspapers, and celluloid intentionally resorted to sensationalism in order to boost TRP ratings and ensure a healthy cash flow. Some of the interesting rebuttals included ideas like: ‘Nothing sells like violence, bloodshed,celebration of the anti-hero (as Jack Nicholson as the Joker in the film Batman) and somehow the glorification of crime as something that gives a sort of vicarious thrill!’
Finally the teacher did step in not that he wanted to, but then he had to tell them that they had done a good job, apart from the minor deviations they had made from the expectations mentioned in the rubric. The session was concluded with a parting shot by their teacher with the words, ‘Both the media and the society are interconnected and to blame one and praise the other would be unfair logically!’ and then he beat a hasty retreat having whipped up another round of interjections, rebuttals, and observations. The teacher was pleased, however with the way the events had taken place, and what mattered the most was the level of engagement that was displayed by the participants. Strangely enough the students had followed the norms of the parameters of the debate which had been clearly written on the green board. The arguments might have bordered on a high level of excitement, but then the credit went to the students who accepted the boundaries of acceptable etiquette.

Tuesday, 4 February 2014

The use of soft-skills by teachers can help reduce violent tendencies in students

The recent incident of a school boy killing a teacher teacher and a police officer dead in a Moscow school highlights the issue of violence in school as a global phenomena not limited to the Columbine incident, or for that effect the stabbing of a school teacher in a Trans-Yamuna school in Delhi a few years back. While preliminary reports point towards a conflict between the accused and his Geography teacher in the Moscow incident, the incidents that took place in Delhi a few years back was because the teacher wouldn’t allow the grad eight student to cheat in the examination. The student stabbed the lady teacher with a sharp object-a knife in all possibility. What connects both the incidents is that it was a clash or a conflict between a student and a teacher.
It goes without saying that teachers should also be given regular training in soft skills rather like the training that School Counselors and Human Resource Personnel are given in the Corporate Sector. The difference however between the school environment and the environment in the Corporate field is that the while the HR executive has to deal with grown ups and adults who might be more amenable to reasoning, the teacher however has to deal with students who are neither adults nor children, and moreover they would be struggling with the process of growing up, hormones playing spoil-sport with their minds, and the pressure to conform to popular and accepted trends among peers. Perhaps some training in soft-skills might have averted both the incidents that have been described above!
While experts suggest that an “emotional breakdown” might have been the reason for the school boy in Moscow shooting his teacher, the result of a long period of a clash of egos and points of view, in the Trans Yamuna school it was a more spontaneous out come of frustration at not being able to cheat in the exam. Two different incidents, separated in time and Geography and perhaps even the fact that one was pre-meditated while the other was spontaneous; but then linked together by the nature of the violence! The problem of violence on school campuses would be tackled very differently by moralists, counselors, or even those who are trained to handle difficult people like Cabin Crew in airplanes, and those dealing with a large number of the members of the public, as for example those manning ticket booths, or bank tellers. One can go on to suggest that successful public servants who are able to diffuse difficult situations before they turn ugly are either born pacifiers loads of patience, or they have received a training of soft skills or for that effect it is a combination of both. I have seen Cabin Crew attempting, quite successfully in most cases, to pacify irate passengers on board airplanes, and the same might be said of Public Relations officers who with their suave demeanor and soft tone are able to satisfy their clients.
The situation in schools could be more challenging than those that I have mentioned above for the very reason that students, especially those who are passing through the phase of puberty and hormonal changes are very difficult to handle through a confrontational attitude. It is never a good idea to enter into an argument with a student in class even if you have to make a hasty retreat to try another day and convince him about the right answer. It has been observed that students who get into an argument with the teacher soon forget the matter within moments and often they realize their mistake if the teacher backs out of the argument gracefully with his or her honor intact a difficult task, no doubt! This, incidentally is what marks the teacher as being more mature than his student, in  a category that marks him or her as a true teacher of life and not just theorems and tense forms.Child Psychologists will point out repeatedly that students have frequent mood swings and tempers that flare up only to fade away as if they never existed!
So, what then happened to aggravate the matter in both the incidents? As far as the Geography teacher in Moscow is concerned,  it could very well be that he had ignored the signs of discontent and feelings of having been affronted in front of his classmates in his students and probably stuck to his guns! As far as the lady teacher in the Trans-Yamuna school, it could have been that she didn’t read the signs of extreme aggression in the student an pressed on to ensure that he didn’t cheat. This doesn’t mean that she should have tolerated a case of cheating, rather she could have called for back-up or handled the issue in a more tactful manner, standing at the head of the row quietly, a battle of patience, wits and the dignity of being a teacher. There are levels of  escalation in such cases, where the teacher doesn’t confront the student directly. The first stage would be to stand before the student, the second stage of handling the situation would be a non-verbal signal, a raised eyebrow, the third would be  a  whispered verbal warning, and the last stage would be calling for back up. In many cases, this process would still result in aggravation in the student after school hours. To handle this scenario, it would be pertinent to take the Principal into confidence. The final note is that the teacher should not, in any case confront the student who refuses to stop from unfair means in exams.
A case study that deserves to be considered is a situation that takes place in a grade eight class. This was a lively class and students were eager to answer questions that had been put up by the teacher. One particular girl, a student who has issues in her family, a mother who has taken ill constantly raises her hands, the teacher gives her a chance to answer the question and then moves on to the other students.  After some time, (this student keeps raising her hands but the teacher ignores her because he wants to give others a chance to answer questions) the students break downs in class ( apparently the result of stress from the situation at home). A few of her classmates gather around her to comfort her. The first thing the teacher does is to shoo away the other students.He asks why she is crying, and she answers that the teacher was not listening to her. Very calmly, he bends down to maintain an eye level contact with the student. He doesn’t in any way pat her since the school maintains a “no touch policy”. Next he talks to her and tells her that he cares for her but then he has to listen to the other students who need to be listened to. After he sees that she has softened down, he tells her that she should now dry up her tears! She feels happy for the attention that the teacher has given to her. Things go back to normal and the class resumes. The trainee teacher who was observing the class expresses her amazement at how the situation was handled. It did not require rocket science to handle the situation involving a girl student who perhaps wanted some sympathy and attention from the teacher, all for herself!
Take as an example another case study. The students of a more senior class, grade nine, take up the issue of why the teacher had cut marks for not citing sources, references for a book review, or for that effect, a list of suggested reading. In this case, their regular teacher had left them quite suddenly. The rubric clearly mentioned the inclusion of a list of references in the rubric for the book review.The teacher quietly listened to the complaints of the students, then very firmly he told the students that the school did not tolerate plagiarism, and that the least they could do was to cite the sources that they had used to draft their book review. The dissenting voices were stilled, since most of them had plagiarized from the internet. Firm but gentle reminder of plagiarism, and the threat of running the reviews through the net to check for plagiarism quietened them a great deal. Finally, there was total silence in the class and the task in hand, a debate exercise could take place, but not before the teacher told the students that he had nothing personal against them, and that he thought they were capable of better work especially as he had a high opinion of them. The dissent in this case was quelled through a right dose of firmness which was fair, since the teacher had reminded them about the rubric which included the need to cite references. The students of this class have worked very hard to be really good debaters, especially with the teacher moderating the debates in a judicious manner. No doubt, it was a battle won through fair means specially since it was based on firmness based on set principles an an honest communication of the fact the teacher thought that this was not personal, it was not based on partiality, but that it was based on principles.
One case study that suggests that the student was handled badly, however relates to a student who came to school with a bottle of liquor. The class teacher handed him over to the Principal of the school. The Principal then went on to berate him and threatened to call his parents. The student somehow managed to escape from the Principal's room, went to the roof and flung himself down to the ground. An unhappy ending which might have been averted if the teacher had kept a more watchful eye on the student, not allowing the matter to reach such proportions.
Yet another case study relates to a student who was not given his admit card in grade twelve for the board exams because of shortage of attendance. The student came to school, had an argument with the Principal, went and smashed his fists into a window pane. He had to be rushed to the dispensary and ultimately was given the admit card. This did send a wrong signal across to the other students in the school that you can get away with a display of violent behavior.  Ideally, this situation could have been averted if the class teacher had given constant feed back about the low attendance of the student to his parents and even taken a written undertaking from the parents that they would ensure that their ward would come to school regularly. Perhaps more counseling would have averted this situation from taking such a bad turn.
In yet another case, a student came to school with a bread knife purportedly for cutting a friend's birthday cake. Later investigations suggested that he had brought the knife wrapped in paper and kept in his bag to warn or threaten a student who had been bullying him. The knife itself might have been for intimidation only, but then who knows what could have transpired during an altercation or a confrontation between both students. The father of the boy who had brought the knife to school was called and he gave his son a good tongue-lashing. The Principal however didn't let the matter rest, and he kept a constant rapport with the student, counseling him and guiding him in the best possible ways. This rapport helped the boy overcome his sense of frustration, and more over the bully who had been troubling him backed of after being given appropriate counseling along with a stern warning.
It is clear from the above case studies that it requires a judicious mix of strategies to ensure that students do not in any way feel slighted or that the teacher has adopted a partial attitude towards them. What matters here is an honest communication and the ability to connect to the students in the class. It doesn’t harm if the teacher communicates honestly the challenges before him and that he expects the students to cooperate to make the session as fruitful and interesting as possible! The takeaway in the second case is that teachers need to be honest communicators who are firm and yet tolerant. The students have a new respect for the teacher. In this case the teacher was not intimidated by the combined voices of the students and he stuck to his guns because he was able to convince the students that not citing sources was a major weakness, and the fact that plagiarism was a major factor in their not getting the marks that they would have got.
Human nature is complex and no single strategy can be pegged as being the best strategy for quelling dissent in students. Often however, it is a combination of just firmness backed by accepted protocols, a dose of appreciation based on reality and positive conditioning based on appreciation for accepted behavior that really work in the favor of the teacher. In all these cases, a less pro-active and balanced approach would have resulted in the distancing or alienation of the teacher from the students. It is often the case that students are not born aggressive, it is rather the circumstances that make them garrulous and aggressive. It is for the teacher to identify these problem areas and work on them. The ideal teacher in any case is one who has immense stores of patience, and the ability to lend an ear to students who might feel neglected and in some cases affronted or ignored.Teaching in any case is not about the teacher displaying his superior knowledge, rather it is about the teacher showing willingness and patience to listen to the students’ point of view, mulling over it and then tactfully giving his observations in such a way that the student sees his error in better light. When a student realizes that the teacher cares for him, he or she automatically tries to reciprocate the same with respect. In times when the role of the teacher takes over the role of a mentor or a parent figure, it becomes all the more important for him or her to develop a ranges of soft skills which include patience, the ability to listen to better ideas, and a firm understanding of the fact that the teacher is today more a facilitator than a store house of knowledge and information!

Sunday, 2 February 2014

A Sunday Visit to the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church at Sohna


OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
Sunday Mass being conducted at the impromptu space cleared for Sundays-At the lectern is Revd. Sunil Ghazan and seated at the far right in white is Evangelist  Anand Beck who is looking after the church in Sohna
When I went to Church this Sunday, I was asked by some of the members of the Church whether I would be accompanying them to the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church at Sohna after Mass, and I said, “Why not?” I would be visiting the Church at Sohna after a good five or six years. When I last visited the Church at Sohna, all they had was a small room barely twenty feet by ten feet. The name Sadhu Sunder Singh reminds us about the travelling evangelist who preached the Gospel in the early twentieth century.
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
On the way to the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church in Sohna
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
The Hall of the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church-its generous space will accommodate a large number of worshipers!
When we reached the Church at Sohna, we were surprised to see how much the place had changed. In place of the one room chapel was a massive structure coming up. We could see that the building when complete would be a beautiful one, what with the beautifully designed arched windows and a building shaped in the form of a cross. The basic shell of the building at Sohna reminded me of the old  building of the Epiphany Church in Gurgaon, and the Holy Trinity Church, Ghaziabad. Pastor Anand Beck was conducting Sunday Mass when we reached and soon Communion would be served. So, after a brief sitting at the hastily cleared part of the newly put up building, we proceeded outside to look at the building that is being built. The new building of the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church at Sohna will have two floors and it will be spacious enough to seat quite a large number of members.
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
A Group photograph of the members of the congregation of the Church of The Epiphany Gurgaon along with the Presbyter in Charge of The Epiphany Church of Gurgaon and Evangelist Anand Beck who is looking after the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church in Sohna
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
I was there too!
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
We were there too! In the picture you can see Baba Masih, Miss Edith Newton, the treasurer of the Epiphany Church of Gurgaon, and Noel Chandekar
Lunch had been organized for us by the members of the Sadhu Sunder Singh Church at Sohna and being hungry after the drive from Gurgaon, we all fell on to what had been prepared for us. After lunch, we then decided to visit the new Graveyard located in Sector 56, in Gurgaon. Earlier, during the rainy season in the months of July and August, it had been in a bad state, what with water-logging and a wall that had been washed away by flood waters. When we saw the place, we could see that the whole ground had been levelled out with soil and debris which had been trucked from construction sites around the place.The Gardener had apparently taken pains to  plant flower bearing plants along the inner boundaries of the Graveyard.
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
At the Graveyard in Sector 56, Gurgaon
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
On the Grounds of the Graveyard in Sector 56, Gurgaon-Mr Sonu Masih, Mr. D.D.Lal, and Mr. Noel Chandekar
Bee Feeding on Nectar
The Bee seemed to symbolise the paradox of life!